• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The FreshDirect Blog

Recipes and news from the northeast's leading online grocer.

  • Recipes
  • Producer Stories
  • FreshDirect News
  • Sustainability
  • Eat With The Season
  • Shop
  • Show Search
Hide Search

10 Grilled Cheese Sandwich Ideas for Every Occasion

Linda Segatto · September 8, 2015 ·

Grilled cheese: the king of easy weeknight dinners; the blank slate of culinary goodness, upon which we pile our hopes, dreams, and favorite cheeses; the gooey, warm, golden, and delicious answer to whatever ails us.

Did I oversell it? That’s impossible! Like the burger or the omelet, grilled cheese has an endless amount of permutations, making it accessible, crowd-pleasing, and never boring. Recently, I used our easy, frozen Pullman loaves (defrost the slices as you need them and the rest stays in the freezer) to make a few different sandwiches, one to fit each of my grilled cheese moods.

Grilled Cheese

1. For when you’re feeling fancy…

Grilled Cheese
Brie and Green Apple Grilled Cheese Sandwich

For this sandwich, I used the cinnamon-raisin Pullman, creamy, mild brie, and slices of green apple. Once the bread was golden and the brie nice and melted, I topped the sandwich with a spring mix dressed in a simple balsamic vinaigrette, just to add a little bite.

The bread also works great with sharp cheddar and red apple slices. A little bacon on either certainly wouldn’t hurt so if you’re looking for a salty layer, try it out. Other great additions: fresh figs or fig spread, prosciutto, toasted pecans.

2. For when you’re feeling spicy…

Jalapenos pack a punch, so I’m always looking for new ways to use them that will spice things up without, you know, setting my tongue on fire. For this grilled cheese, I cut up four peppers, took out all the seeds, and roasted them in the toaster oven for about 20 minutes on 350° F. I used sourdough bread, melted slices of Colby Jack cheese (though I think this sandwich would also be great with cheddar, pepper jack, provolone, etc), and added the roasted jalapenos on top. The end product tastes like a jalapeno popper—if you have teenagers to feed, they’ll be all over this.

3. For when you’re feeling nostalgic…

Grilled Cheese
Tuna Melt

Fancy, high-quality cheeses are good most of the time. But sometimes I just want a greasy spoon tuna melt, the kind you’d find at your favorite hometown diner.

I like my tuna melt on the hearty whole wheat Pullman, but this sandwich is also great on any thick, crusty bread. I chop up dill pickles and add them to my tuna with salt, pepper, and mayo. The secret to this melt: Kraft singles. Make sure to add a slice to each piece of bread for extra melty goodness. You can even throw on some tomato to class things up.  (If you don’t like Kraft singles, Muenster cheese is a good substitute.)

For all your other feelings…

4. Melted cheese comes in many forms—steak sandwiches, panini, nachos. Quesadillas are an easy (and cheesy!) after-school snack: Just heat your tortilla in the pan like you would grilled cheese, layering cheese and veggies in the middle and folding over, and serve with sour cream and salsa.

5. Breakfast grilled cheese: everything bagel (use the inside of the bagel to grill and cut the rounded part to make it square), fresh creamed cheese, tomato

6. Black olive loaf with sharp parmesan

7. Italian bread with ricotta, mozzarella, fresh basil, tomato (Alternate: provolone and pepperoni)

8. White bread with strawberry, melted chocolate, and brie

9. Brioche Pullman bread with pear, honey, mascarpone

10. Rye bread with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut

What are your favorite grilled cheese sandwich recipes? Let us know on the FreshDirect Facebook page or via Twitter (@FreshDirect)

Filed Under: Dinner, Easy DIY, Eat With The Season, Lunch Tagged With: dinner ideas, Make More Meals, recipes, Savor the Season, Try Something New

Primary Sidebar

Search

Browse Posts

Read More

Get Social With FreshDirect

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Instagram

@FreshDirect On Instagram

View on Instagram
Summer calls for seafood. A shrimp & clam boil may be the perfect way to celebrate the season. A boil featuring fresh shellfish is a super easy way to enjoy all your favs in one dish. 

Here’s how it’s done: 
Cut an onion into quarters. Halve a head of garlic horizontally. Add 1 1/2 inches of water to a stock pot, followed by onion, garlic, 2 bay leaves, and 1 tbsp Old Bay seasoning. Bring to a boil on the stove. Once boiling, add one bag of whole, small potatoes (such as Blushing Belle). Let cook a couple minutes. In the meantime, cut 2 andouille sausages (or more, if you like) into 1 1/2-inch pieces, then add to boiling pot. Cut 4 ears corn into smaller segments and add to pot. Continue to boil for another 5 minutes. Gather 2 lb shrimp (preferably shell-on), 1 dozen clams and 1 lb mussels. Toss seafood with a few drizzles of neutral oil and 1 tbsp Old Bay. Add to pot, cover, and cook 2 to 3 minutes. Remove from heat and let rest 1 minute before transferring to a platter for serving. Season with more Old Bay, if you like.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Summer calls for seafood. A shrimp & clam boil may be the perfect way to celebrate the season. A boil featuring fresh shellfish is a super easy way to enjoy all your favs in one dish. Here’s how it’s done: Cut an onion into quarters. Halve a head of garlic horizontally. Add 1 1/2 inches of water to a stock pot, followed by onion, garlic, 2 bay leaves, and 1 tbsp Old Bay seasoning. Bring to a boil on the stove. Once boiling, add one bag of whole, small potatoes (such as Blushing Belle). Let cook a couple minutes. In the meantime, cut 2 andouille sausages (or more, if you like) into 1 1/2-inch pieces, then add to boiling pot. Cut 4 ears corn into smaller segments and add to pot. Continue to boil for another 5 minutes. Gather 2 lb shrimp (preferably shell-on), 1 dozen clams and 1 lb mussels. Toss seafood with a few drizzles of neutral oil and 1 tbsp Old Bay. Add to pot, cover, and cook 2 to 3 minutes. Remove from heat and let rest 1 minute before transferring to a platter for serving. Season with more Old Bay, if you like.
3 days ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
Our interns help make FreshDirect great! We’re celebrating all that they do and wishing them a bright future.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Our interns help make FreshDirect great! We’re celebrating all that they do and wishing them a bright future.
6 days ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
Mezze foods are an assortment of eastern Mediterranean snacks like stuffed grape leaves, olives, pita bread, and hummus.

Use the link in our bio to treat yourself by using our freshest ingredients to build your own mezze platter.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Mezze foods are an assortment of eastern Mediterranean snacks like stuffed grape leaves, olives, pita bread, and hummus. Use the link in our bio to treat yourself by using our freshest ingredients to build your own mezze platter.
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
It’s Love Local month here at FreshDirect. All through August, we’ll be featuring local partners in support of businesses committed to bringing incredible flavors to our communities and neighborhoods.

Show some love by shopping your favorite local brands on our site! ❤️
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
It’s Love Local month here at FreshDirect. All through August, we’ll be featuring local partners in support of businesses committed to bringing incredible flavors to our communities and neighborhoods. Show some love by shopping your favorite local brands on our site! ❤️
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
from one proud BX resident to another, it was an honor to take part in the special tradition that is @yankees Old-Timer’s Day 🗽⚾️ #repbx
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
from one proud BX resident to another, it was an honor to take part in the special tradition that is @yankees Old-Timer’s Day 🗽⚾️ #repbx
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
Ready for lobster season🦞? Our very own Senior Merchant Mike is here to show you how to prepare the most delicious Maine lobster for the summer.

Head over to FreshDirect.com to take advantage of our Lobster Party Sale!
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Ready for lobster season🦞? Our very own Senior Merchant Mike is here to show you how to prepare the most delicious Maine lobster for the summer. Head over to FreshDirect.com to take advantage of our Lobster Party Sale!
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
✨ magic in the Hamptons with @casadelsoltequila ✨
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
✨ magic in the Hamptons with @casadelsoltequila ✨
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
Chill. Crack. Sip. Ahh. These beers and seltzers are super flavorful, easy to enjoy, and perfect for making any summer day a bit of a celebration.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Chill. Crack. Sip. Ahh. These beers and seltzers are super flavorful, easy to enjoy, and perfect for making any summer day a bit of a celebration.
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
With a little bit of summer in every bite, s’mores make the perfect backyard treat this season. In five simple steps, these s’mores bites are an easy, fun option to enjoy.

1. Melt chocolate chips in the microwave in 30-second increments, stirring often.
2. Break up your graham crackers into bite sized pieces and put them in rows on the parchment paper.
3. Place a marshmallow on each graham cracker.
4. Spoon the melted chocolate sauce on top of the marshmallows and graham crackers until they are engulfed in chocolaty goodness.
5. Pop the baking tray into the freezer for 10-15 minutes, or until the chocolate is hardened.

Stock up on everything you need to create this chocolatey, gooey masterpiece.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
With a little bit of summer in every bite, s’mores make the perfect backyard treat this season. In five simple steps, these s’mores bites are an easy, fun option to enjoy. 1. Melt chocolate chips in the microwave in 30-second increments, stirring often. 2. Break up your graham crackers into bite sized pieces and put them in rows on the parchment paper. 3. Place a marshmallow on each graham cracker. 4. Spoon the melted chocolate sauce on top of the marshmallows and graham crackers until they are engulfed in chocolaty goodness. 5. Pop the baking tray into the freezer for 10-15 minutes, or until the chocolate is hardened. Stock up on everything you need to create this chocolatey, gooey masterpiece.
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
9/9