All About Utopia Bagels – History, Flavors, & More

Here’s something we can all agree on: There isn’t much out there that beats a good, wholesome bagel!

Whether you prefer a simple bagel with cream cheese or a bagel breakfast sandwich, the most important component is the bagel itself—you want a bagel that’s crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and boasts an incredible flavor profile.

For this perfect bagel flavor, Utopia Bagels is the answer. 

Let’s dive into the world of Utopia Bagels, including flavors available, their history, and why it’s best to order them from FreshDirect!

What flavors are available?

You’ll find all of your favorite classic bagel flavors available with Utopia—and some unique ones, too! Here are 11 of our favorite Utopia Bagel varieties. 

Sesame Bagels

A New York Classic—does it get better than a well-made sesame bagel? We don’t think so!

The sesame bagel is a staple in all bagel shops around the world, and Utopia’s Sesame Bagels live up to the hype. The sesame seeds maintain a crispy exterior that combines with a soft interior—creating a classic bagel taste that you know and love. Whether you’re a simple cream cheese person or a bagel sandwich person, you can never go wrong with the classic Utopia Sesame bagel! 

Everything Bagels

Onion, garlic, salt, poppy seeds, sesame seeds—they all come together to create one of the best bagels around: The everything bagel! 

Utopia Everything Bagels make a superb breakfast (or lunch and dinner!), from classic cream cheese to intricate breakfast sandwiches that make your mouth water. Our unique bagel flavor brings a classic like the everything bagel to the next level—add your favorite toppings and enjoy! 

Mixed Bagels

Can’t decide which bagel you want in the morning? We know the feeling—they’re all great! 

Instead of fighting indecisiveness, we have the solution. The Utopia Bagels Mixed Bagel bag is the best of all worlds, allowing you to switch up your morning breakfast based on what you’re feeling. The Utopia Mixed Bagel bag contains five of their famous bagel flavors: Sesame, Poppy, Rye, Whole Wheat, and Pumpernickel. Change it up daily and enjoy!

Plain Bagels

Different flavors are cool, but sometimes the classics are what you need.

When done right, it’s hard to beat a plain bagel—and Utopia always does it right. The Utopia Bagels Original Plain Bagel has been using the same recipe since 1981, delivering a bagel that’s soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. All that’s left is to add your favorite spread, and you’ve got a tasty breakfast for your busy mornings!

Plain Mini Bagels

Everyone loves a classic plain bagel. But what about those times when you want a snack but don’t want the full bagel? Don’t worry, Utopia has you covered.

Utopia’s Plain Mini Bagels pack all of the same unique flavors and use the same recipe as our regular bagels—with a crunchy exterior and soft inside. Add your favorite toppings for an irresistible snack at any time of the day. No matter the occasion, these plain mini bagels will never let you down! 

Blueberry Bagels

Sweettooths—you can never go wrong with a tasty blueberry bagel—no matter what time of day it is. 

Utopia’s Blueberry Bagel taste is out of this world, with the classic crispy exterior and soft interior with the sweet taste of fresh blueberries. Heat before serving, and the smell of fresh blueberries will fill your kitchen. Whether you prefer butter, cream cheese, or any other topping, Utopia Blueberry Bagels always bring the flavor! 

Egg Bagels

How do you take the classic bagel flavor up a notch? Add eggs to the recipe!

Utopia Bagels Egg Bagel touches upon everything you look for in a fresh and tasty bagel: Crunchy, soft, sweet, savory and the perfect consistency. It’s a classic that you won’t regret starting your morning with or having as a mid-day snack—whichever you prefer! 

Everything Flats

The classic everything bagel flavor—except with an unbeatable crunch this time! 

The Utopia Bagels Everything Flat Bagel gives you a wide palette of flavors combined with the perfect crunch in every bite. Utopia Everything Flats are flattened by hand, making a larger crispier outside with less dough inside. Simply toast and top with your favorite spread and you’ve got the perfect breakfast, snack, and everything in between! 

Bagel Assortment

An assortment of ten different bagels and two different flavors of cream cheese—does it get any better than that? We don’t think so. After all, everyone loves a package deal!

This Bagel Assortment from Utopia Bagels has just what you need for the ultimate New York breakfast: Ten bagels in classic, mouthwatering flavors, along with plain and scallion cream cheeses for adding a nice schmear. No matter what you’re in the mood for, this bagel assortment has what you need!

Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

Can you name a more iconic duo than cinnamon and raisins?

Impossible—especially when you combine them in a mouthwatering bagel that satisfies every time. Utopia’s Cinnamon Raisin Bagel is the ideal choice for those mornings when you want something sweet and delicious. With an iconic flavor spanning several decades, you can’t go wrong with a Utopia Cinnamon Raisin Bagel—it always hits the spot! 

Rainbow Bagels

What if you could have your favorite bagel taste in a fun and unique package? 

With Utopia’s Rainbow Bagels, that’s exactly what you get! These fun rainbow bagels bring you a burst of the seven different colors of the rainbow without sacrificing the classic Utopia taste that you know and love. Who says you can’t have fun while you eat? Enjoy the iconic Utopia flavor with our unique Rainbow Bagels! 

Gluten-Free Plain Bagels

The same great plain bagel taste that you know and love — but completely gluten-free!

For those with gluten intolerance or sensitivities, you’ll love these gluten-free plain bagels. Baked with the same care as our other products, this collaboration with Original Sunshine brings you an incredible-tasting bagel without the trouble of gluten. 

Gluten-Free Everything Bagels

Now you can get the explosion of flavor you expect from a tasty everything bagel in a gluten-free package! 

We know you’ll love the gluten-free everything bagel — it’s packed with all of the onion, garlic, salt, poppy seed, and sesame seed flavors you know and love. Perfect for those with any gluten sensitivities, it’ll be a hit at breakfast, for a quick snack, or any other time that you love to eat bagels! 

Who is Utopia Bagels?

Utopia Bagels is a neighborhood favorite bagel shop founded in 1981 in Whitestone, NYC, by Scott Spellman and Anthony Pantaleo. Despite there being many other bagel shops in the area, Utopia set themselves apart by also providing a friendly and family-like atmosphere for customers. 

Customers are also drawn to Utopia Bagels because of their commitment to using only the finest ingredients and traditional methods of bagel-making. Each bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and then baked to perfection in a 1947 carousel oven. This process results in a bagel that is crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and has a distinct flavor that is hard to replicate—the renowned Utopia bagel flavor! 

In addition to their classic bagels such as plain, sesame, and poppy seed, Utopia Bagels also offers a variety of unique flavors such as cinnamon raisin, blueberry, and everything. Their signature rainbow bagels have also become a fan favorite, with their vibrant colors and fun design making them a popular choice for social media posts.

Despite the shop’s success and recognition, Utopia Bagels has remained true to their roots and continues to prioritize quality over quantity.

Overall, Utopia Bagels is more than just a bagel shop. It is a testament to the artistry and dedication that goes into creating the perfect bagel. 

Ordering Utopia Bagels from FreshDirect

What’s better than having top-tier bagels with unbeatable flavor? How about a simple delivery straight to your front door!

FreshDirect gives you the opportunity to have your favorite Utopia Bagel flavors delivered to you with no fuss. If you live in select areas in NYC, you’ll have express same-day delivery within two hours. For the rest of the city, New Jersey, Connecticut, Staten Island, and Long Island, you’ll have convenient next-day delivery.

FreshDirect is one of only two retailers that sell Utopia Bagels. They’re frozen bagels, but don’t worry—they don’t taste like your regular everyday frozen bagel. Your ordered bagels will provide the same mouthwatering taste as the ones sold fresh in their Whitestone location!

There’s nothing better than an unbeatable bagel flavor delivered to you with no effort needed. You can find more information about FreshDirect delivery here

Get all of your favorite Utopia Bagel flavors delivered straight to your door

Ready to have the perfect bagel delivered to you in record time? 

Whether you’re looking for blueberry, sesame, or the unique rainbow flavor—we’ve got you covered. Order all of your favorite Utopia Bagel flavors from FreshDirect today!

Shop Utopia Bagels of New York on FreshDirect