Do you remember the time before fall meant the arrival of pumpkin spice everything? We do, and we’re not quite sure how we ever got by without that gourd-geously sweet flavor and those soul-warming spices gracing the better part of our autumn eating itinerary. But the food gods are kind and now there’s a glut of pumpkin-packing treats. So many, in fact, that trying to keep up makes our jack-o-lantern heads spin.

So we sought out the coolest pumpkin spice products in the patch, the ones that made us stop in our tracks and say “you can put pumpkin in that?!” Check out our top picks below.

You can shop all of them here on FreshDirect. Just bear in mind that supplies may be limited depending on how big this season’s pumpkin spice pandemonium is.

Califia Pumpkin Spice Latte Cold Brew

OK, so this might be another version of your PSL. But it comes in a bottle. That you can keep in your fridge. For all those must have pumpkin spice now!!! emergencies. Plus, it’s made with Califia’s delightful fair-trade coffee and extremely delicious AlmondMilk (hello, dairy-free). And you don’t have to wait in line for it at a coffee shop where they always misspell your name.

Purely Elizabeth Pumpkin Cinnamon Ancient Grain Granola

This granola brings together pumpkin seeds with amaranth, quinoa, and chia, for a breakfast or snack time treat that has the perfect crunchy texture and lots of autumnal flavor. Layer it with pumpkin yogurt (see below) and some slices of apple or pear, and you’ve got an appropriately seasonal parfait that’ll give you all the fall feels. Bonus: it’s gluten-free!