• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The FreshDirect Blog

Recipes and news from the northeast's leading online grocer.

  • Recipes
  • Producer Stories
  • FreshDirect News
  • Sustainability
  • Eat With The Season
  • Shop
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Thanksgiving Main Dishes That Aren’t Turkey

Miki Kawasaki · November 4, 2020 ·

Maybe you’re having a smaller gathering or going the Friendsgiving route. Or perhaps your holiday meal is so epic it calls for a bevy of showstoppers. There’s also the chance you’re cooking for vegans, vegetarians, or someone who just doesn’t think turkey’s worth the hype (trust us, you’re not alone). That’s when it’s time to think out of the box for Thanksgiving and choose one of the many other tasty celebratory options. Not sure where to start? We’ve got you covered.

Poultry, Beef & More Meaty Mains

Chicken

You could think of it as downsizing, but this member of the poultry family arguably has the most to offer when it comes to flavor. Your average 4–5 lb. whole chicken is big enough for up to four guests (or two very hungry ones). Or you could go the personal route and give each diner their very own petite Cornish hen. Roasting either of these will take a fraction of the time needed to do a whole turkey.

Season your chicken with salt, pepper, and a few fresh herbs for the epitome of sophisticated simplicity. Or you could try a fun new marinade or rub (we’ve even got a few pre-marinated options to make things extra effortless). This might also be a great opportunity to upgrade from your usual poultry and try a flavorful heritage bird. And if you’re just trying to use Thanksgiving day to chillax, no one is ever going to raise an eye at a delicious rotisserie chicken.

Get our recipe for Simple Roast Chicken.


Beef

Nothing says luxury quite like a good piece of beef. And in most cases, it doesn’t need any more than the most basic seasonings. For a grand centerpiece, a standing rib roast is about as regal as it gets. There many other great whole beef cuts to choose from—chuck roasts are a favorite if you’re trying to stick to a budget, while a filet mignon roast is great if you prefer something lean.

You could also go with steaks, especially if you’re feeding a smaller crowd. For celebratory occasions, well-marbled cuts like rib-eyes and strip steaks are classic go-tos, along with highly tender options like filet mignon and top sirloin.

Get our basic steak recipe.


Lamb

Like beef, you can either opt for one grand roast or a few more petite chops when you’re serving lamb for a feast. A rack of lamb or a lamb leg roast is your best bet when you’re looking to turn heads, or rib chops are great for treating just a few people to one of the most flavorful and tender cuts of all. You could also go in a totally different direction by making a hearty braised lamb shank, which is one of the most comforting dishes you could ask for when the weather is starting to get cold.

Get our braised lamb shank recipe.


Pork

There are so many ways to go decadent with pork, from whole loins to racks of ribs to shoulder and butt roasts. When it comes to celebratory meals, however, ham might just be the king of them all. You may think of it as Christmas fare, but that hardly matters once you get a taste of its incredible marriage of salty, sweet, and savory flavors. Plus, it’s hard to beat if your favorite part is the leftovers.

Shop all pork cuts.


Seafood

If you’re pre-gaming or having a Friendsgiving party before the main Thanksgiving meal, a seafood-centric spread will kick off the holiday in style. You’ll be sure to impress with a dazzling whole-roasted fish or a few trays of shellfish. Or use the special occasion to make that seafood recipe you’ve always wanted to try—there’s always room to create a new tradition!

Shop seafood for Thanksgiving.


Vegetarian & Vegan Options

There will always be room for plant-based “roasts” at the table of any veggie-centric feasts, and they occupy a special place in the hearts of anyone who prefers to forgo the meat. But you might get more satisfaction and nutritional bang for your buck by focusing on dishes made with whole veggies. Plus, nothing will put you in a cozy mood quite like some carbs (lots and lots of carbs). Simply mix and match your faves, or have everyone bring a dish potluck style. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • No-Recipe Veggie Side Dishes For Thanksgiving
  • Classic Green Bean Casserole
  • Rich and Creamy Mashed Potatoes
  • Homestyle Baked Macaroni and Cheese
  • Cheesy Potato Gratin
  • Gluten-Free Sweet Potato Casserole
  • Roasted Parmesan and Herb Sweet Potatoes
  • Crunchy Thanksgiving Slaw
  • Roasted Butternut Squash with Greek Yogurt
  • Butternut Squash, Kale, and Apple Salad
  • Butternut Squash and Chickpea Salad
  • Butternut Squash, Sage, and Garlic Gratin
  • Apple Rosemary Couscous
  • Easy Stuffed Artichokes

Shop Everything Thanksgiving on Freshdirect

Filed Under: Meat, Poultry, Produce, Recipes, Seafood, Thanksgiving

Primary Sidebar

Search

Browse Posts

Read More

Get Social With FreshDirect

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Instagram

@FreshDirect On Instagram

View on Instagram
Create this easy heirloom tomato grain bowl using the African supergrain fonio (brought to us by our friends at @yolelefoods !)

Here’s how to make it:
Start by preparing the fonio according to the package directions, then top with fresh corn, heirloom tomatoes, crispy cucumbers, feta cheese, red onion, and mint. Drizzle with a bit of balsamic, olive oil, and coarse sea salt, then dig in!
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Create this easy heirloom tomato grain bowl using the African supergrain fonio (brought to us by our friends at @yolelefoods !) Here’s how to make it: Start by preparing the fonio according to the package directions, then top with fresh corn, heirloom tomatoes, crispy cucumbers, feta cheese, red onion, and mint. Drizzle with a bit of balsamic, olive oil, and coarse sea salt, then dig in!
1 day ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
Veggies taste better when they’re local, and they taste even better when they’re from Hepworth Farms. But don't just take our word for it, try them for yourself.

Hepworth Farms’ is a 7th generation family farm in Milton, NY whose commitment to “dechemicalization” has yielded them over 400 varieties of organic produce.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Veggies taste better when they’re local, and they taste even better when they’re from Hepworth Farms. But don't just take our word for it, try them for yourself. Hepworth Farms’ is a 7th generation family farm in Milton, NY whose commitment to “dechemicalization” has yielded them over 400 varieties of organic produce.
4 days ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
In honor of FreshDirect's 20th Anniversary celebration, some of our longest-tenured employees are being recognized for their contributions over the years. Our next 20th Anniversary Employee Spotlight is Teofila Rijos, a Personal Shopper in our Ambient/Dry Goods department.

Q: What's your favorite part about working at FD?
A: In sickness and in health, my team and FreshDirect have always supported me.

Q: What's something you've learned by working at FD?
A: I’ve worked in different departments and learned something new from each of them.

Q: What does working at FD allow you to do in your personal life (go to college, support your family, buy a house, send your kids to school, travel to see your family, etc.)
A: Working at FreshDirect has taught me structure. Each job has a process that has to compliment others. This has helped me improve how I structure my life out of work.

Q: What's a goal or a dream that you have?
A: My dream is to open a restaurant somewhere outside of New York. I believe the skills FreshDirect has taught me will help me excel as a business owner.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
In honor of FreshDirect's 20th Anniversary celebration, some of our longest-tenured employees are being recognized for their contributions over the years. Our next 20th Anniversary Employee Spotlight is Teofila Rijos, a Personal Shopper in our Ambient/Dry Goods department. Q: What's your favorite part about working at FD? A: In sickness and in health, my team and FreshDirect have always supported me. Q: What's something you've learned by working at FD? A: I’ve worked in different departments and learned something new from each of them. Q: What does working at FD allow you to do in your personal life (go to college, support your family, buy a house, send your kids to school, travel to see your family, etc.) A: Working at FreshDirect has taught me structure. Each job has a process that has to compliment others. This has helped me improve how I structure my life out of work. Q: What's a goal or a dream that you have? A: My dream is to open a restaurant somewhere outside of New York. I believe the skills FreshDirect has taught me will help me excel as a business owner.
5 days ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
Summer calls for seafood. A shrimp & clam boil may be the perfect way to celebrate the season. A boil featuring fresh shellfish is a super easy way to enjoy all your favs in one dish. 

Here’s how it’s done: 
- Cut an onion into quarters. Halve a head of garlic horizontally. 
- Add 1 1/2 inches of water to a stock pot, followed by onion, garlic, 2 bay leaves, and 1 tbsp Old Bay seasoning. Bring to a boil on the stove. 
- Once boiling, add one bag of whole, small potatoes (such as Blushing Belle). Let cook a couple minutes. 
- In the meantime, cut 2 andouille sausages (or more, if you like) into 1 1/2-inch pieces, then add to boiling pot. Cut 4 ears corn into smaller segments and add to pot. Continue to boil for another 5 minutes. 
- Gather 2 lb shrimp (preferably shell-on), 1 dozen clams and 1 lb mussels. Toss seafood with a few drizzles of neutral oil and 1 tbsp Old Bay. Add to pot, cover, and cook 2 to 3 minutes. 
- Remove from heat and let rest 1 minute before transferring to a platter for serving. Season with more Old Bay, if you like.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Summer calls for seafood. A shrimp & clam boil may be the perfect way to celebrate the season. A boil featuring fresh shellfish is a super easy way to enjoy all your favs in one dish. Here’s how it’s done: - Cut an onion into quarters. Halve a head of garlic horizontally. - Add 1 1/2 inches of water to a stock pot, followed by onion, garlic, 2 bay leaves, and 1 tbsp Old Bay seasoning. Bring to a boil on the stove. - Once boiling, add one bag of whole, small potatoes (such as Blushing Belle). Let cook a couple minutes. - In the meantime, cut 2 andouille sausages (or more, if you like) into 1 1/2-inch pieces, then add to boiling pot. Cut 4 ears corn into smaller segments and add to pot. Continue to boil for another 5 minutes. - Gather 2 lb shrimp (preferably shell-on), 1 dozen clams and 1 lb mussels. Toss seafood with a few drizzles of neutral oil and 1 tbsp Old Bay. Add to pot, cover, and cook 2 to 3 minutes. - Remove from heat and let rest 1 minute before transferring to a platter for serving. Season with more Old Bay, if you like.
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
Our interns help make FreshDirect great! We’re celebrating all that they do and wishing them a bright future.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Our interns help make FreshDirect great! We’re celebrating all that they do and wishing them a bright future.
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
Mezze foods are an assortment of eastern Mediterranean snacks like stuffed grape leaves, olives, pita bread, and hummus.

Use the link in our bio to treat yourself by using our freshest ingredients to build your own mezze platter.
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Mezze foods are an assortment of eastern Mediterranean snacks like stuffed grape leaves, olives, pita bread, and hummus. Use the link in our bio to treat yourself by using our freshest ingredients to build your own mezze platter.
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
It’s Love Local month here at FreshDirect. All through August, we’ll be featuring local partners in support of businesses committed to bringing incredible flavors to our communities and neighborhoods.

Show some love by shopping your favorite local brands on our site! ❤️
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
It’s Love Local month here at FreshDirect. All through August, we’ll be featuring local partners in support of businesses committed to bringing incredible flavors to our communities and neighborhoods. Show some love by shopping your favorite local brands on our site! ❤️
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
from one proud BX resident to another, it was an honor to take part in the special tradition that is @yankees Old-Timer’s Day 🗽⚾️ #repbx
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
from one proud BX resident to another, it was an honor to take part in the special tradition that is @yankees Old-Timer’s Day 🗽⚾️ #repbx
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
Ready for lobster season🦞? Our very own Senior Merchant Mike is here to show you how to prepare the most delicious Maine lobster for the summer.

Head over to FreshDirect.com to take advantage of our Lobster Party Sale!
@freshdirect
@freshdirect
•
Follow
Ready for lobster season🦞? Our very own Senior Merchant Mike is here to show you how to prepare the most delicious Maine lobster for the summer. Head over to FreshDirect.com to take advantage of our Lobster Party Sale!
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
9/9