Jeni's Ice Cream, High Five Candy Bar

Four ingredients to rule them all: Peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels. Plus one not-so-secret ingredient — honey — which gives our peanut butter ice cream a dreamy, nougat-y texture and flavor. Think of eating this flavor like digging for buried treasure. There's something fun to be found in every single bite! (from Jeni's)