Delivery

​
Start typing, then use the up and down arrows to select an option from the list.

Perfect Pairs: Grilled Cheese + Tomato Soup

Say cheese! We're still in love with this classic pair that'll take you back to childhood. Stick to the classics with white bread and cheddar (and #allthebutter) and dunk away in rich, velvety soup.
New York State Cheddar Extra-Sharp
New York State Cheddar Extra-Sharp
current price $12.49/lb
Cabot Vermont Cheddar
CabotVermont Cheddar
current price $13.49/lb
Finlandia Cheddar Gruyere
FinlandiaCheddar Gruyere
current price $10.49/lb
Shelburne Farms 2-Year Cheddar
Shelburne Farms2-Year Cheddar
current price $24.49/lb
Cabot 50% Light Vermont Cheddar
Cabot50% Light Vermont Cheddar
current price $13.99/lb
1655 Cave-Aged Gruyère AOP
1655 Cave-Aged Gruyère AOP
current price $35.99/lb
Livardois French Raclette
Livardois French Raclette
current price $17.99/lb
FreshDirect Domestic Swiss Cheese
FreshDirectDomestic Swiss Cheese
current price $10.99/lb
Lancaster Farm Fresh Cooperative Local Organic Yellow Onions
Express
Lancaster Farm Fresh CooperativeLocal Organic Yellow Onions
current price $4.49/ea
approx. 4ct & 2lb bag
FreshDirect Pepper Jack Cheese
FreshDirectPepper Jack Cheese
current price $9.79/lb
Plum Tomatoes
Express
Plum Tomatoes
current price $3.99/ea
approx. 1lb bag
Challerhocker
Challerhocker
current price $38.99/lb
FreshDirect Toum Whipped Garlic Dip
FreshDirectToum Whipped Garlic Dip
current price $6.99/ea
$0.87/oz8oz
Divina Fig Spread
Express
DivinaFig Spread
current price $4.99/ea
$0.55/oz9oz
Divina Sour Cherry Spread
DivinaSour Cherry Spread
current price $7.49/ea
$0.83/oz9oz
Divina Peruvian Pepper Jam
DivinaPeruvian Pepper Jam
current price $7.49/ea
$0.88/oz8.5oz
Isigny Ste Mère Beurre D'Isigny, Salted Butter
Isigny Ste MèreBeurre D'Isigny, Salted Butter
current price $6.99/ea
$0.79/oz8.8oz
Bread Alone Organic San Francisco Sourdough
Express
Bread AloneOrganic San Francisco Sourdough
current price $5.99/ea
$0.27/oz22oz, 16 slices ea
Bread Alone Organic Peasant Bread
Express
Bread AloneOrganic Peasant Bread
current price $5.99/ea
$0.33/oz20oz, 16 slices ea
Newlight Breadworks Seeded Semolina Sourdough Bread
Newlight BreadworksSeeded Semolina Sourdough Bread
current price $7.49/ea
$0.27/oz28oz, 14 slices ea
Newlight Breadworks Milk Bread
Newlight BreadworksMilk Bread
current price $7.49/ea
$0.54/oz14oz, 8 slices ea
Tom Cat Bakery Japanese Milk Sandwich Bread
Tom Cat BakeryJapanese Milk Sandwich Bread
current price $8.49/ea
$0.65/oz13oz ea
Sliced Organic, Paris Dark Round
Eli's BreadSliced Organic, Paris Dark Round
current price $10.49/ea
$0.44/oz24oz
Brooklyn Mills E.V.O.O. Sliced Sourdough Spelt Bread, Frozen
Brooklyn MillsE.V.O.O. Sliced Sourdough Spelt Bread, Frozen
current price $6.49/ea
$0.54/oz12oz, 6 slices ea
Brooklyn Mills Panino Sandwich Rolls, Frozen
Brooklyn MillsPanino Sandwich Rolls, Frozen
current price $8.49/ea
$0.47/oz4ct
Brooklyn Mills Handcrafted Whole Wheat Pita Bread
Brooklyn MillsHandcrafted Whole Wheat Pita Bread
current price $5.49/ea
$0.37/oz5ct, 15oz
Horizon Organic Salted Butter
Horizon OrganicSalted Butter
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz4ct, 4oz ea
Toasted Parmesan Crisp
Express
Eli's BreadToasted Parmesan Crisp
current price $14.49/ea
$3.62/oz4oz
FreshDirect Frozen Classic Focaccia
FreshDirect FrozenClassic Focaccia
current price $6.49/ea
$0.41/oz1lb
Orwashers Cabernet Rustica, Sliced, Frozen
OrwashersCabernet Rustica, Sliced, Frozen
current price $6.49/ea
$0.41/oz16oz
Orwashers Thick Sliced Righteous Rye Boule, Frozen
It's Back
OrwashersThick Sliced Righteous Rye Boule, Frozen
current price $6.49/ea
$0.50/oz13oz, 8 slices ea
Brooklyn Mills Foccacina Romana Rolls
Brooklyn MillsFoccacina Romana Rolls
current price $8.49/ea
$0.71/oz4ct, 12oz
Soup, Zuppa Toscana
Pika's Farm TableSoup, Zuppa Toscana
current price $13.49/ea
$0.64/oz21oz
Soup, Lemony Chicken
Pika's Farm TableSoup, Lemony Chicken
current price $13.49/ea
$0.64/oz21oz
Pika's Farm Table Soup, Smokey Tomato and Chicken Bisque
Pika's Farm TableSoup, Smokey Tomato and Chicken Bisque
current price $13.49/ea
$0.64/oz21oz
Pika's Farm Table Soup, Kale Quinoa
Pika's Farm TableSoup, Kale Quinoa
current price $9.49/ea
$0.43/oz22oz
Ladle of Love Soup, Moroccan Red Lentil
Ladle of LoveSoup, Moroccan Red Lentil
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz16oz
Ladle of Love Soup, Chunky Vegetable
It's Back
Ladle of LoveSoup, Chunky Vegetable
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz16oz
Ladle of Love Soup, Potato Leek
Ladle of LoveSoup, Potato Leek
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz16oz
Breakstone's Salted Butter
Breakstone'sSalted Butter
current price $8.99/ea
$0.56/oz4ct, 4oz ea
Breakstone's Unsalted Butter
Breakstone'sUnsalted Butter
current price $8.99/ea
$0.56/oz4ct, 4oz ea
Oregano
Oregano
current price $2.49/ea
Save 19%
approx. 2oz
Organic Basil
Express
Organic Basil
current price $3.99/ea
approx. 2oz
Ladle of Love Soup, Split Pea
Ladle of LoveSoup, Split Pea
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz16oz
Ladle of Love Soup, Tuscan Tomato
Ladle of LoveSoup, Tuscan Tomato
current price $11.49/ea
$0.72/oz16oz
FreshDirect Chili, Local Grass-Fed Beef
FreshDirectChili, Local Grass-Fed Beef
current price now$8.29/ea earlier price was$9.29
Save 10%
$0.52/oz16oz
FreshDirect Soup, Matzo Ball
FreshDirectSoup, Matzo Ball
current price $13.49/ea
$6.75/pt32oz, 2pcs
FreshDirect Soup, Chicken Noodle
FreshDirectSoup, Chicken Noodle
current price $13.49/ea
$0.42/oz32oz
FreshDirect Soup, Cream of Tomato
FreshDirectSoup, Cream of Tomato
current price $7.49/ea
$0.47/oz16oz
FreshDirect Specialty Cheese Board
FreshDirectSpecialty Cheese Board
current price $96.99/ea
Serves 12-15